Have you seen this Article?
Please, go read it.
And please, be as disgusted and disturbed as I am by it. By the words, the opinions and the fact that this magazine and the editor allowed it to be published.
And here, here is the letter I wrote to the editor of Marie Claire. Will it ever get read? Who knows? I needed to say it, so I did.
And I will NEVER purchase this magazine again.
Dear Ms. Coles,
I am writing in response to a recent article by Ms. Maura Kelly. I am quite sure you know which article I am referencing. I wasn't a regular reader of Marie Claire, I had been in my early 20s but I have since turned to magazines that I find to suit me more. I will occasionally pick up a copy of your magazine if there is a story on the front cover that catches my eye. This story did not. I was emailed this article by a friend and I was immediately outraged. Not only was I outraged as a former "Fattie" but also as someone who continually struggles with her weight, someone who has worked very hard in the past year to lose close to 40 pounds and as someone who is the mother of a daughter who has to grow up in a world where women like Ms. Kelly and individuals like you and your editors think it's appropriate to refer to people based simply on their size and their struggles.
I work very hard to raise my daughter and my son to understand that people are different and that each day we encounter individuals who may be struggling or bearing some type of pain or hardship in their life. We also encounter people who have incredible self-confidence and self-respect regardless of their size. Your article, and subsequently, your magazine are simply feeding into the societal stereotype that says that being fat is bad and wrong and being skinny is right and good. You tout yourself as a magazine for young women and women who are looking for tips to make their lives better yet you publish horribly offensive articles that clearly state that being obese is something that can easily be changed with a personal trainer or a trip to the YMCA.
Shame on you.
I feel for Ms. Kelly, I really do. Not only did she feel it was appropriate to write the horrible hate-filled and uneducated words that she did but then she had to step up and apologize for those words. She had to reveal that her words MAY have come out of a history of eating issues and anorexia. First of all, I can say with almost 100% certainty her horrible words MUST have come from a history of eating issues and anorexia. Second of all, if she cannot own the words and opinions that she wrote maybe she should not have written them. And finally, I feel for her because it must have been hard to come out and admit that she had an eating problem and needed help- much as it is difficult for obese people to come out and admit that they may have a problem and need help.
Ms. Coles, really, I am disappointed in your magazine and your premise as being there for women. You, in this case, are no where near to being there for any of us. I cannot believe that any editor would allow such a piece of mean-spirited writing to published in a magazine such as yours, or any. I can also tell you that I will NEVER purchase Marie Claire again and my daughter never will. I will also make sure that I share this with all of the "fatties" and non-"Fatties" I associate with.
Thank you for your time,
Friday, October 29, 2010
Have you seen this Article?
Posted by Alison McGeary-Stella at 10:58 AM